Hank Greenberg

Greenberg’s résumé is a “what if” because the counting totals would be even bigger without lost prime seasons. Even with that time gone, his rate production shows he was one of the most dominant hitters of his era. He combined huge power with strong on-base ability, which is the exact profile this position should maximize. The monster home run seasons weren’t empty; they came with elite run creation and run driving. He carried offenses in pennant races and consistently ranked among league leaders in key categories. His peak was MVP-level force, and the context of his era makes the separation even more impressive. When you adjust for missed time, you’re looking at a player who could have threatened the very top tier statistically. He also produced with consistency, not just one lightning-bolt year. Offensively, he’s a true franchise pillar, and that’s why he’s top five here.